eStockes publishes 20-year comparison of eight daily trading rules
eStockes' 20-year backtest of eight trading rules across five US ETFs found all 19 rule-fund combinations underperformed buy-and-hold but had smaller maximum drawdowns.

eStockes has published a historical study of eight commonly used trading rules across five US-listed funds. The study ran 19 predefined rule-and-fund combinations from 13 November 2006 to 13 November 2026. All 19 ended with less money than buying and holding the same fund over the same period. All 19 also recorded a smaller maximum drawdown. These results describe the test window and settings.
The tests used daily market data from Twelve Data for SPY, QQQ, IWM, DIA and GLD. The rules were evaluated at the close and trades were modelled at the next session's open. The tests included dividends and modelled slippage of two basis points per trade side on the four equity funds and five on GLD. The rule simulations excluded commissions and taxes. The buy-and-hold benchmark assumed no trading costs. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
The report publishes results for each rule-and-fund pair, including time invested and the number of trades, alongside its assumptions and limitations. Comparing the two outcomes on the same fund and dates lets readers see the trade-off between time in the market and the depth of historical losses.
Read the study and its methodology: https://estockes.com/learn/trading-rules-vs-buy-and-hold
Readers can also try a simple daily rule themselves with eStockes Reality Check. The free browser tool compares the rule with holding the same stock or ETF and displays its own date range and cost assumptions. It works without an account: https://estockes.com/reality-check
Notes to editors
Publisher: eStockes, a stock research and education platform operated by Eylon Sabag, an independent sole proprietor registered in Israel.
Notes to editors
- Organisation
- eStockes
- Contact
- Eylon Sabag
- Website
- https://estockes.com/
Contact details are hidden from automated harvesters. Click to show them.